|
Randy Cassingham's BlogHistorical Details and Author's Notes from This is True®
|
The Exploitation of Saaya Irie
The story about Saaya Irie in the 22 May 2005 issue was a tad disturbing by itself, but what really brought the story home was the photos that were the topic of the story. That story -- and a couple of example photos of an unusually ...uh... mature 11-year-old girl, are here. On this page, reaction to the story and the photos.
Free Weird Newsletter
|
True has always been about social commentary, using stupid things people do as its launching pad. The girl can be excused -- she's only 11, so presumably her parents are there to help her make decisions. And they're doing a spectacularly bad job. Now, thanks to that, their daughter is being used as a political pawn. You better believe I have something to say about that! As for making you think, that is, after all, the idea. Clearly, the story helped you focus your own thoughts and express them well, so I have to believe I've done a very good job at prompting thought, even among those who find the images disturbing.
- "I couldn't help but wonder at the minds of the people behind the 11-year-old girl's pictures and campaign. Using an 11-year-old child in this way is just wrong. Even if she is an unusually well-endowed 11-year-old. Is it any wonder why we live in a world full of social decay, when this is the sort of thing that the media exports around the world? Keep fighting the good fight against all this stuff, and the insane 'Zero Tolerance' in schools, and all the rest of it.... Maybe send some GOOHF cards to the Japanese girl, and the kids in the ZT stories -- I've got a feeling they'll need them." --Jon, U.K.
It's a fine line to toe: how to comment on the situation without being a mere party to her exploitation. I did obviously decide to publish a couple of photos of the girl with the story; I have found over the years that the way to make people think twice about doing weird things isn't to ignore them, but to confront their acts head on and expose their actions for what they really are -- in this case, exploitation. If the girl were old enough to make an informed decision, I'd be fine with it, even if her decision was to exploit herself. But she's not old enough, and the adults she is depending on have put her in a pretty rough place. It's quite possible she'll come out of it just fine; I hope so. Meanwhile, I have succeeded in making a lot of people think about the issue. My mail is about 40-1 in favor of my decision to run the story and the photos, so I think I've succeeded in keeping "within the line".
It took several weeks, but I finally got the letter I was waiting for:
- "Am I the only one upset about the political reason behind this exploitation -- that the Japanese were attempting to 'whitewash war crimes' in their history books? I'm not sure which is worse -- that the Japanese are trying to 'bribe' the Chinese into accepting a rewrite of history by showing them [clothed] juvenile breasts or that Chinese men seem to be buying into it. The rape of Nanking? Who cares, look at these breasts! That's frightening. If I saw this in a movie (and it wasn't an obvious parody of the human condition) I would think how totally unrealistic it is. And I'd be wrong." --Dan, Illinois
Congrats, Dan: it's about danged time that someone really understood the real message of the story!
RSS
Most Recent Comments
Posted by Charles ,San Diego on April 25, 2009:
Im going to have to agree with Randy ,andy LA sounds like a [pardon my french ] dumbass
---
Yes, you are. READ what I said to you on your first post. I could tell you were the same guy without even looking. Now bugger off -- I have better things to do than deal with your pedophillic urges. -rc
Posted by Nick, Aus on June 15, 2009:
The national age of consent is not 16 in Japan. It's 16 here in Australia. In Japan, it is 13.
Yeah, you might say that she is still 2 years shy of the age of consent. But you forget that the age of consent is the age at which a person can legally consent to sexual relations. Not the age at which they can pose completely non-nude.
Australia can get pretty bad sometimes too, but this is a prime example of America's prudish nature and insensitivity to other cultures. Japan is not America. The sooner you learn that, the better.
Posted by James, Los Angles on August 10, 2009:
I agree with what Nick from Australia posted on June 15th, 2009. Americans are all too often notoriously known as the Police of the world (watch Team America if you don't know what I'm talking about). We tend to impose our beliefs and values on other societies even without taking the time to understand the other society. I've lived in Japan, and so I have first-hand knowledge of how different the two cultures are. But we can't ignore the fact (although it makes us Americans very uncomfortable) that we as human men are naturally attracted to women who have matured through puberty, no matter what age they happen to be. The woman's body changes in order to bear children. And as a result, the opposite sex is naturally going to be attracted, and the Japanese society (both men and women) holds less shame about that. In fact, they have much less shame surrounding sex than the rather sexually conservative United States has.
The argument might be made that we as higher beings (now 400+ years beyond the time of Romeo and Juliet) should shame away that attraction. I mean, otherwise, we'd be animals, right?
Now that Saaya is a bit older, she's enjoying success in other ventures such as her musical group "Chase". Further, how is Saaya much different from Miley Cyrus, who at 15 had some rather racy photos taken of her own or, perhaps, the Olson twins or Vanessa Hudgens (granted they were slightly older).
I guess only time will tell if Saaya's really been exploited, as this site purports. One thing you might be surprised to learn is how respectful the Japanese are in sharp contrast to Americans. Perhaps from our perspective inside our disrespectful society... we can't even imagine such a thing!