Weird News Video #47: Red, White and Blue House - Comments
Posted by
Denise, High Point, NC on June 1, 2009:
I live in High Point, and I'm sorry to say I'm not surprised by the idiocy that went into this commercial. You should see the commercials for the you-pull-it auto salvage yard with its busty babes in scanty clothes suggestively advertising the "self-help" facility.
---
I should? Then send a tape! ;-) *cough*. "The Red House" nothing -- more like "The Red Neck".... -rc
Posted by
"Fish" (David B. Trout) -- Bellevue, WA on June 2, 2009:
I personally think it's a stupid commercial, but more than that I also found it to be somewhat offensive because race has nothing whatsoever to do with selling furniture. The fact that their commercial attempted (but failed miserably IMHO) to make fun of racial discrimination (presumably to drive home the irrationality of its practice) is wholly immaterial in IMO. The fact that they brought it up even though they and everyone else (except perhaps the completely ignorant) already knew it has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with selling furniture is wrong and in and of itself offensive.
It's as if like they're subtly implying that race does usually make a difference for certain things in life (such as buying furniture). The fact that they're claiming (in a non-humorous way IMO) that it doesn't at their particular store makes no difference since they shouldn't have even brought it up in the first place!
Anyway, that's my 2 cents on the issue: it was a stupid (non-funny) commercial that due to its failed attempt to make light of the race issue ended up falling flat on its face, more than likely offending their potential customers instead of making them laugh.
Posted by
Jay L in Cambridge, MA on June 2, 2009:
@Fish gets the gist; I think the spot is trying to make fun of the idea that racism could even enter the furniture-sale transaction.
Sadly, it fails; it's a potentially funny premise, but it can't be the whole joke. Neither can the "Look ma, no budget!" production.
To see this type of parody done properly, watch Mr. Show with Bob and Dave. A four-season HBO sketch comedy featuring Bob Odenkirk and Arrested Development's David Cross, it often used fake commercials as transitions.
One episode had a David-and-Goliath theme, with some local grocer being driven out of business by the Big Bad Chain. They have some dueling advertising spots, something like:
LOCAL FARM STAND: I'm gratified by the community support here. Don't worry about the Big Chain; we'll be here, neighbor to neighbor, selling you the best produce we can grow.
BIG CHAIN: Now open! Finally, a store that has the resources to buy the quality produce you deserve; none of that second-rate, bug-ridden pig slop you see in other stores.
LOCAL: My grand-daddy taught his son, and so on, and we give you the juiciest corn and the freshest tomatoes. No pesticides or preservatives, just good old-fashioned nature.
CHAIN: Worried about your apples? You won't find any worms in ours; unlike some, we spray our apples to keep your family safe.
LOCAL: B-but... organic...
CHAIN: Yes, we're the place to come when you don't want dead children screaming in the aisles.
LOCAL: There were absolutely no deaths! This is the.. We're the good guys!
CHAIN: And *our* manager hasn't been convicted for child pornography, either. We're a family store. Your family.
LOCAL: ...
etc.
Posted by
Barbara in Seattle on June 5, 2009:
Words cannot express how dumbfounded I am. Unbelievable!!!
Posted by
Donna, Horton Alabama on June 6, 2009:
Stupid ... Yes.... Got the job done! How many people have now seen this commercial. How many people will make a stop at that location when they are in that area? I've worked in advertising all my life, and I still know "word of mouth" is still the best advertising.
See you at The Red House.
Posted by
Richard in Hudson, NH on June 6, 2009:
Huh?
Posted by
Paul - Sao Paulo, Brazil on June 6, 2009:
A truly stupid, but incredibly effective commercial. People from all over are talking about "The Red House", which is, after all, the point.
---
Your talking about them from Brazil isn't going to help them a bit. Laughing at a company's actions isn't the same as going there and buying things from them because of those actions. Yes, some will, and that's a plus. Others will avoid the company because of the ad, and that's clearly a minus. They obviously hope the net result is a positive, but it remains to be seen whether the long-term effect is up or down. -rc
Posted by
Mark in Silicon Valley on June 6, 2009:
Before taking this commercial too seriously, everyone should realize that it is the product of a North Carolinian comedy team, Rhett and Link. They have produced silly ads for a number of small businesses in the state, primarily as a way of getting their work seen on YouTube. It is the usage of real local business people that gives the videos a genuine "down-home redneck" flavor, which is what the comedians are counting on to get attention for themselves. After all, another slick satire of a bad commercial would be boring, whereas "the real thing" gets YouTube hits and resultant links to the comedians' site.
How frequently these ads actually have been aired on local TV is the question. I doubt that Rhett and Link seriously care about increasing sales at the small businesses themselves.
Posted by
Tom Norfolk, VA on June 6, 2009:
They should have a follow-up commercial to appeal to Greeks. Advertise the Procrustean Bed, the perfect fit for you no matter what your size.
I'm not exactly sure how you could have the Procrustean Bed be perfect for all races, but I'm sure there are some in the area who would have ideas.
Posted by
Colleen, Bound Brook NJ on June 17, 2009:
Amazingly stupid commercial. Folks forget that dumb commercials are how Jim "Ernest" Varney got his start; dumb all the way to the bank....
---
They can definitely work, but great care must be taken to ensure what people think is being made fun of. Jim "Know whut I mean?" Varney made fun of himself, not the product/service or (as perhaps is the case here) the customers. -rc
Weird News Video #47: Red, White and Blue House - Comments
Posted by Denise, High Point, NC on June 1, 2009:
I live in High Point, and I'm sorry to say I'm not surprised by the idiocy that went into this commercial. You should see the commercials for the you-pull-it auto salvage yard with its busty babes in scanty clothes suggestively advertising the "self-help" facility.
---
I should? Then send a tape! ;-) *cough*. "The Red House" nothing -- more like "The Red Neck".... -rc
Posted by "Fish" (David B. Trout) -- Bellevue, WA on June 2, 2009:
I personally think it's a stupid commercial, but more than that I also found it to be somewhat offensive because race has nothing whatsoever to do with selling furniture. The fact that their commercial attempted (but failed miserably IMHO) to make fun of racial discrimination (presumably to drive home the irrationality of its practice) is wholly immaterial in IMO. The fact that they brought it up even though they and everyone else (except perhaps the completely ignorant) already knew it has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with selling furniture is wrong and in and of itself offensive.
It's as if like they're subtly implying that race does usually make a difference for certain things in life (such as buying furniture). The fact that they're claiming (in a non-humorous way IMO) that it doesn't at their particular store makes no difference since they shouldn't have even brought it up in the first place!
Anyway, that's my 2 cents on the issue: it was a stupid (non-funny) commercial that due to its failed attempt to make light of the race issue ended up falling flat on its face, more than likely offending their potential customers instead of making them laugh.
Posted by Jay L in Cambridge, MA on June 2, 2009:
@Fish gets the gist; I think the spot is trying to make fun of the idea that racism could even enter the furniture-sale transaction.
Sadly, it fails; it's a potentially funny premise, but it can't be the whole joke. Neither can the "Look ma, no budget!" production.
To see this type of parody done properly, watch Mr. Show with Bob and Dave. A four-season HBO sketch comedy featuring Bob Odenkirk and Arrested Development's David Cross, it often used fake commercials as transitions.
One episode had a David-and-Goliath theme, with some local grocer being driven out of business by the Big Bad Chain. They have some dueling advertising spots, something like:
LOCAL FARM STAND: I'm gratified by the community support here. Don't worry about the Big Chain; we'll be here, neighbor to neighbor, selling you the best produce we can grow.
BIG CHAIN: Now open! Finally, a store that has the resources to buy the quality produce you deserve; none of that second-rate, bug-ridden pig slop you see in other stores.
LOCAL: My grand-daddy taught his son, and so on, and we give you the juiciest corn and the freshest tomatoes. No pesticides or preservatives, just good old-fashioned nature.
CHAIN: Worried about your apples? You won't find any worms in ours; unlike some, we spray our apples to keep your family safe.
LOCAL: B-but... organic...
CHAIN: Yes, we're the place to come when you don't want dead children screaming in the aisles.
LOCAL: There were absolutely no deaths! This is the.. We're the good guys!
CHAIN: And *our* manager hasn't been convicted for child pornography, either. We're a family store. Your family.
LOCAL: ...
etc.
Posted by Barbara in Seattle on June 5, 2009:
Words cannot express how dumbfounded I am. Unbelievable!!!
Posted by Donna, Horton Alabama on June 6, 2009:
Stupid ... Yes.... Got the job done! How many people have now seen this commercial. How many people will make a stop at that location when they are in that area? I've worked in advertising all my life, and I still know "word of mouth" is still the best advertising.
See you at The Red House.
Posted by Richard in Hudson, NH on June 6, 2009:
Huh?
Posted by Paul - Sao Paulo, Brazil on June 6, 2009:
A truly stupid, but incredibly effective commercial. People from all over are talking about "The Red House", which is, after all, the point.
---
Your talking about them from Brazil isn't going to help them a bit. Laughing at a company's actions isn't the same as going there and buying things from them because of those actions. Yes, some will, and that's a plus. Others will avoid the company because of the ad, and that's clearly a minus. They obviously hope the net result is a positive, but it remains to be seen whether the long-term effect is up or down. -rc
Posted by Mark in Silicon Valley on June 6, 2009:
Before taking this commercial too seriously, everyone should realize that it is the product of a North Carolinian comedy team, Rhett and Link. They have produced silly ads for a number of small businesses in the state, primarily as a way of getting their work seen on YouTube. It is the usage of real local business people that gives the videos a genuine "down-home redneck" flavor, which is what the comedians are counting on to get attention for themselves. After all, another slick satire of a bad commercial would be boring, whereas "the real thing" gets YouTube hits and resultant links to the comedians' site.
How frequently these ads actually have been aired on local TV is the question. I doubt that Rhett and Link seriously care about increasing sales at the small businesses themselves.
Posted by Tom Norfolk, VA on June 6, 2009:
They should have a follow-up commercial to appeal to Greeks. Advertise the Procrustean Bed, the perfect fit for you no matter what your size.
I'm not exactly sure how you could have the Procrustean Bed be perfect for all races, but I'm sure there are some in the area who would have ideas.
Posted by Colleen, Bound Brook NJ on June 17, 2009:
Amazingly stupid commercial. Folks forget that dumb commercials are how Jim "Ernest" Varney got his start; dumb all the way to the bank....
---
They can definitely work, but great care must be taken to ensure what people think is being made fun of. Jim "Know whut I mean?" Varney made fun of himself, not the product/service or (as perhaps is the case here) the customers. -rc
Read the article that everyone's commenting on, or post a comment about it.